Caraway Cookware vs Always Pan

Within the modern nonstick cookware space, direct-to-consumer disruptors Caraway and Always Pan earn rave reviews for reimagining functionality for home kitchens. While founded just years apart with sustainability missions, key differences in their offerings, materials and performance determine which innovator truly best suits your cooking lifestyle.

Caraway Cookware vs Always Pan Comparison

This guide thoroughly compares Caraway cookware and Always Pan across factors like product range, coating distinctions, heating abilities, convenience, design aesthetics and price considerations. Use this breakdown to decide which rising company provides the ideal pots and pans that match your needs and tastes.

Brief Company Histories

Caraway: Launched in 2017 by two entrepreneurs from NYC setting out to reinvent nontoxic, nonstick cookware using safer materials free from harmful chemicals. Their ceramic-coated pots and pans specifically target starter sets.

Always Pan: Created in 2019 by a startup seeking to condense kitchen clutter into one high-functioning nonstick pan. Their modular lid and stainless steamer basket intend to consolidate numerous appliances into one affordable piece.

While both founders came from tech backgrounds noticing holes in the cookware market, Caraway concentrates on perfecting core materials and pots/pans while Always Pan pursues versatility consolidating uses.

Types of Materials Used

The biggest differences lie in the main compositions:

Caraway: Uses a German-made ceramic nonstick coating free of PTFE & PFOAs made from minerals and sand. Their pan interiors feature an aluminium core while bases have stainless steel plates.

Always Pan: Constructs their signature pan using a “Ceramic NonStick” coating containing Teflon derivatives and polymers but no PFOAs. The body utilizes aluminium for responsiveness and conductivity when cooking.

Material Comparison

FeaturesCarawayAlways Pan
Main CoatingCeramic NonstickCeramic NonStick (Contains Some PTFE/Polymers)
Base MaterialAluminum CoreCast Aluminum
PFOA Free?YesYes
PTFE Free?YesNo

So while both offer ceramic style nonstick, Caraway avoids any Teflon in theirs while Always Pan admits using Teflon derivatives.

Product Ranges

Both brands offer skillets and sauce pots essential for everyday cooking but differ vastly in scope:

Caraway: Provides deliberate curation focusing just on core nonstick pans and two set sizes designed for 1-4 person households. Accessories like sheets and mitts are available.

Always Pan: Built an entire brand around their single signature skillet/pot hybrid designed to replace numerous one-use small appliances. Aside from the hero pan, they offer speciality baking dishes and accessories.

If seeking a basic cookware set for standard kitchen demands, Caraway equips homes better. But Always Pan’s consolidating skillet conveniently combines the functions of over 8 appliances.

Performance & Durability Comparison

Evaluating daily use functionality, Caraway Cookware and Always Pan both satisfy home cooks well but achieve optimal results differently:

Heating Responsiveness: Always Pan’s cast aluminium composition reacts quickly and evenly to temperature changes. Caraway’s aluminium core also heats up fast but may exhibit minor hot spots.

Estimated Lifespan: Caraway guarantees 3 years but both should reasonably last 5+ years with proper maintenance. The Always Pan may show wear sooner from heavily mixed-use cycles.

Nonstick Convenience: Caraway promises effortless food release every time without oil or butter needed. Always Pan requires light seasoning for an ideal nonstick effect when cooking.

Results Summary: While Always Pan masters rapid heating, Caraway edges them out slightly for the most forgiving nonstick performance straight out of the box. Both prove user-friendly for average home demands without commercial-grade intensity.

Performance Comparison

FeaturesCarawayAlways Pan
Heating AbilitiesVery GoodExcellent
Estimated Lifespan5+ years3-5 years
Nonstick ConvenienceEffortlessRequires Preseasoning

Design & Style Differences

Beyond performance, visual appeal and decor coordination help drive cookware buying decisions.

Caraway markets a distinctly minimalist modern aesthetic through:

  • Neutral Tones
  • Coordinated Nested Lid Sets
  • Gentle Lines
  • Wood Accents

By contrast, the Always Pan focuses on simple utilitarianism featuring:

  • Matte Warm Finishes
  • Rounded Edges
  • Streamlined Look
  • Modular Lid & Handles

Caraway suits contemporary trends with matching sets while Always Pan keeps things simple as an incognito workhorse pan.

Price Point Considerations

Thanks to direct-to-consumer models bypassing retailers, both brands price competitively compared to premium cookware labels. However, differences exist:


  • $95+ per frying pan
  • $395-$545 for cookware sets

Always Pan:

  • $145 for their signature skillet/pot hybrid
  • $50-95 for accessories

For entire cookware sets, Caraway offers outstanding value accommodating more basic kitchen needs. But considering versatility consolidating numerous appliances, Always Pan’s hero piece presents a reasonable cost as an all-in-one solution.

Determining the Best Brand for You

Given similar founding innovations but different advantages, is one better than the other? The right choice depends on the individual cook’s needs.

Caraway excels for folks wanting:

  • Matched sets of essential pots & pans
  • Consistent nontoxic ceramic
  • Sleek coordination for contemporary kitchens

Always Pan perfects the needs of cooks valuing:

  • Consolidation replacing many appliances
  • Streamlined yet functional design
  • Multipurpose usefulness beyond frying

Read all comparison posts here:


Both companies make cooking more convenient for modern households but in different ways. Caraway provides deliberately designed nonstick while Always Pan smooths workflow. Identify which strengths suit your space and habits best in determining if Always Pan or Caraway products feel like the smartest solutions for your needs.

All the kitchen items that we review in the form of blog post on this website are thoroughly and well researched and most importantly, i and my family members personally use it before we publish any content. We are 100% sure of it.